I understood completely upon reading it for the first time that when TC said he thought it was the worst controller he had ever felt, it was his first impression upon using it for the first five minutes. Then he immediately said he wanted to try it again because he doesn't trust his own first impression, which is rational. People in this topic are being a little ridiculous.
Also, I'd be surprised if the guy who took the time to make the only stickied topic on the board was trolling it.
I also did not like the controller, I tried a demo unit controller and used it for a bit, it had a weird feel to hold it, the sticks were incredibly small (I have huge fingers), the a,b,x,y buttons felt weird to press, and the triggers and bumpers just felt awkward, the d-pad was better but still not the best d-pad I've used. The controllers I like are Xbox original,360,PS1,PS2,PS3 and Gamecube. I have yet to try a PS4 controller but I've heard good things, although that's what I also heard for this.