I love TPS games, Uncharted was the reason I got a PS3 and Gears of War was the reason I got a 360. While I do prefer Uncharted much more (Naughty Dog's are masterful at game creation) I have to say I'm sad that Epic is not really interested in making a Gears of War this gen, they have are involved with more important projects.
We all know that Uncharted and Gears of War were direct rivals being the biggest TPS exclusives on the competing systems, and it feels like Uncharted defeated it. Uncharted 3 and Gears of War 3 released both at the end of 2011, and not only did Uncharted 3 have the higher metacritic but it ended up outselling Gears 3 despite it launching two months later.
Then Gears of War Judgment released last year and hardly anyone cared and it sold poorly. I think that speaks volumes about the mass majority being over the series, while people went ballistic when Sony announced Uncharted PS4 in November
So while I'm super excited about Uncharted PS4, I wish there was a new Gears of War this gen coming as well --- Naughty Dog's "The Last of Us" Gaming has reached a new level (Only on PlayStation)
People didn't get Gears of War Judgment because it was a bad cash in game. Not because they were getting tired of it. --- Xbox Live Gamertag :ShottaSteveUrkel PSN: Hollaatmyfoot PSNvita: ExempliaGratia
They play almost nothing alike. I mean you might as well say that Metroid Prime and CoD are comparable, cuz they're both FPS. Uncharted just has elements to it that are paid attention as much or more than shooting, like its cinematic platforming and puzzles. And Uncharted isn't even over-the-shoulder.