An Objective comparison of MS and Sony exclusives of last gen. Unexpected result

#1IzraeilPosted 3/2/2014 3:31:14 PM(edited)
We hear all the time on gamefaqs about how MS has no good exclusives other than Halo and Gears, and how Sony has no exclusives that sell. I decided to make a list of all the MS and Sony exclusives of last gen in order of their game rankings score along with the sales figures.

Rules for inclusion:
-Only games with a rating of 80%+ on Gamerankings.
-Only Retail games (as there is no sales data available for DD titles)
-Only games owned by MS and Sony
-Ordered by Gamerankings Score


So here it is:

Microsoft:
90+
Gear- 6.03
Halo 3- 11.88
Gears 2- 6.67
Forza 3- 5.39
Halo Reach- 9.53
Gears 3- 5.99
Forza 4- 4.17

80+
Forza 2- 4.01
PGR3- .57
Fable 2- 4.17
Halo 4- 8.96
Dance Central 3 -.71
Dance Central 2- 1.96
Viva Piñata- 1.59
Halo ODST- 6.22
Alan Wake- 1.25
Crackdown 1.71
Viva Piñata 2- .44
Halo Wars- 2.41
Banjo Kazooie- .73
Kameo- .32
Fable 3- 4.94


Sony:
90+
Uncharted 2- 6.35
The Last of Us- 4.34
LittleBigPlanet- 5.40
God of War 3- 4.65
LittleBigPlanet 2- 3.10
Uncharted 3- 6.28
Killzone 2- 2.95
MLB 10- .69

80+
MLB 1- .52
Demon’s Soul- 1.67
Uncharted- 4.71
MLB 09- .70
Heavy Rain- 2.74
R&C ToD- 2.48
R&C ACIT- 1.76
MLB 13- .60
Resistence 2- 2.40
Resistence- 4.23
MLB 12- .87
MLB 08- .69
Killzone 3- 2.58
Infamous- 2.73
Infamous 2- 1.65
GT5- 10.88
Resistance 3- 1.36
Warhawk- 1.03
Modnation racers- 1.04
Moterstorm- 3.80
Singstar- 1.04
Motorstorm 2- 1.29
Buzz!- .85
Hot Shot Golf- 1.11
GT6- 2.05
Quiz TV- .84
Heavenly sword- 1.60


Total sales: MS(89.65) Sony(89.98)
#2krystylaPosted 3/2/2014 2:47:44 PM
6 times MLB and north americans say soccer is boring
---
FC: 4227 - 1514- 7752 IGN:Mara PSN: JudasInHell Gamertag: Schreckstoff
Written by Surface Pro 2 256GB
#3Izraeil(Topic Creator)Posted 3/2/2014 2:50:46 PM
krystyla posted...
6 times MLB and north americans say soccer is boring


Couldn't discount those, plus they barely added any sales to the total, while the 5 Halos on XB1 are the bulk of 360 exclusive sales.
#4krystylaPosted 3/2/2014 2:53:12 PM(edited)
Izraeil posted...
krystyla posted...
6 times MLB and north americans say soccer is boring


Couldn't discount those, plus they barely added any sales to the total, while the 5 Halos on XB1 are the bulk of 360 exclusive sales.


Oh I didn't mean they made an impact it's just funny it's in the list 6 times.

Fable 3 getting 80+ is weird though. Apparently an 8 is really bad nowadays.
---
FC: 4227 - 1514- 7752 IGN:Mara PSN: JudasInHell Gamertag: Schreckstoff
Written by Surface Pro 2 256GB
#5Izraeil(Topic Creator)Posted 3/2/2014 2:54:21 PM
krystyla posted...
Izraeil posted...
krystyla posted...
6 times MLB and north americans say soccer is boring


Couldn't discount those, plus they barely added any sales to the total, while the 5 Halos on XB1 are the bulk of 360 exclusive sales.


Oh I didn't mean they made an impact it's just funny it's in the list 6 times.

Fable 3 getting 80+ is weird though. Apparently an 8 is really bad nowadays.


Yeah it could've been knocked off the list if there was one more bad review.lol
#6RS_YELARAKAPosted 3/2/2014 3:02:33 PM
Was the point of this to show it took 10+ more exclusives on the PS3 to catch XB360 which had the better higher grossing invidual games?

So moral of the story is XB exclusives are better?
---
GT - YELARAKA/RokSteadE (Member of RS Squad)
kcypher2000 said it best
#7krystylaPosted 3/2/2014 3:03:39 PM
RS_YELARAKA posted...
Was the point of this to show it took 10+ more exclusives on the PS3 to catch XB360 which had the better higher grossing invidual games?

So moral of the story is XB exclusives are better?


No because that would imply PS4 is better...
---
FC: 4227 - 1514- 7752 IGN:Mara PSN: JudasInHell Gamertag: Schreckstoff
Written by Surface Pro 2 256GB
#8krystylaPosted 3/2/2014 3:07:16 PM
Okay metacritic just lost all credibility to me Lost Odyssey and Blue Dragon scored below 80 while there's tons of crap on both lists.
---
FC: 4227 - 1514- 7752 IGN:Mara PSN: JudasInHell Gamertag: Schreckstoff
Written by Surface Pro 2 256GB
#9PorungaPosted 3/2/2014 3:11:10 PM
RS_YELARAKA posted...
Was the point of this to show it took 10+ more exclusives on the PS3 to catch XB360 which had the better higher grossing invidual games?

So moral of the story is XB exclusives are better?


yeah... sorry, no.
#10copycat2008Posted 3/2/2014 3:12:05 PM
theres 70% more ps3 exclusive games that are missing in your list.