It depends. The one thing that has me confused about this proposed Halo 1-4 HD Xbox One port is, how are the games exactly going to be handled?
Is it just going to be Halo: CE Anniversary, Halo 3, and Halo 4 all buffed up a bit to be on the Xbox One? And then a brand new Halo 2 Anniversary included in the package? If that's the case, then I guess I'd take this, since it has all four games instead of just Halo 2.
Or are they just going to be rushed, cheap remasters? If the Halo 2 of the entire bundle is going to be dumbed down (like say, not necessarily a brand new remake like CE Anniversary), then I'd rather have the actual Halo 2 Anniversary remake.
I already own CE Anniversary and Halo 3 and 4 on the Xbox 360. So those games are not as important for me to own on the Xbox One. I do, however, really want my Halo 2 Anniversary. It's my favorite Halo game, and one of my favorite games of all time.
So whichever one that would have the better Halo 2, I would want.
IRON MAIDEN IS MY RELIGION! Gamertag: Demigod Elessar
Halo 2 Anniversary. I own all 3 Xbox consoles and multiple copies of every game in the series, so I can go back and play them whenever I want, but getting Halo 2 with updated visuals and terminals would be something new and exciting to entertain myself (plus I look forward to all of the Halo babies that started the series at Halo 3 or Reach struggling to beat Halo 2 on Legendary. They're gonna get wrecked.)
i doubt we get the halo collection AND halo 2 anniversary. Chances are halo 1 will be a port of Halo:CE anniversary and the rest will just be upgraded HD textures or whatever. But I don't see us getting 2 forms of Halo 2 on the Xbox One.