My wifey got me a console bundle for my bday that came with titanfall and watchdogs, I am probably going to keep titanfall merely because I did play it a few times and had a ton of fun with it, however the gameplay I have seen of watchdogs really left me uninterested, I was contemplating returning watchdogs and either getting DR3 or Shadows of Mordor, opinions Gfaqs board?
I think you should keep both because your wife did a nice thing for you and to just trade away her gift would be a jerk move on your part.
Erm there is far better fps and far better open world games coming out so i would be very tempted to trade them both. I played through both but that was during the great gaming drought of early 2014. There is gona be a lot of better options between now and xmas