So I played through Walking Dead and was blown away by how strongly the story gripped me. Even though I know now my actions didn't change any major plot points, I don't care - I felt the weight of each decision I made and it completely engrossed me in a way I don't think any other game has.
That said - the game is over and I am looking for similar experiences. They don't necessarily have to be "point and click adventures" (though I did enjoy that aspect) - just something with a strong story that involves you in some heavy decision making.
Any platform is fine for game recommendations as well, doesn't need to be just 360
Pokemon Black2 FC: 2108 6746 9224 (new player looking for trades) 3DS FC: 4296 4405 8727 (Mario Kart 7)