Now that Gen VI is coming out and it is looking like it'll be a mover and a shaker game, looking back, Gen V was really ill suited to be a reboot. I would have much preferred the whole new region in the new spot in the timeline with a whole new set of Pokemon to go with the new game of the new console with new graphics.
That isn't to say that Gen VI can't or won't do the same thing (although it probably won't be as disconnected with how old Pokemon have been shown), but two in a row doesn't really have the same effect, you know? --- Judicoid Judicator-variant Android
I don't think reboot means what you think it means. Pretty sure many of the ingame text makes gen V to be set years after the other gens. --- "Trouble keeps you running faster, Save the planet from disaster!" ~ Sonic Boom If they turn the tables, just flip them over! - Aegis P4Arena
It was as close to one as Pokemon will probably get, and so is generally referred to as a reboot. It isn't a real reboot, but certainly one of sorts that disconnected itself from the previous games a lot more than the others. --- Judicoid Judicator-variant Android
It was as close to one as Pokemon will probably get, and so is generally referred to as a reboot.
The THIRD gen is the closest Pokemon's likely to get to being a reboot. It's the first (and so far only) time they broke compatibility and made sweeping changes to the underlying system. --- Creator of Jay's Journey (see quote!) "It's not ten years old! Therefore, it sucks!" - Nostalgia whores everywhere
It's funny how on the B/W boards for years I saw the term thrown around without debate and it's now that people want to debate it. After dozens of topics, "reboot of sorts" is ingrained into my mind. --- Judicoid Judicator-variant Android