I've picked Oshawott every time in Gen 5, and unless the evos really screw things up, Chespin's going to be my partner.
In Gen 4 I chose each starter once each though...Torterra's my favourite for going through the game, but Infernape's one of my favourite Pokémon to use competitively. I like them both equally. I think I count :P
Official Floatzel of the Pokemon XY boards Wheel of Time Progress: EotW, TGH, TDR, TSR, [FoH: 2%]