I actually just got White 2, first time playing Pokemon since Silver, and trying to decide which one to pick. Leaning towards the pig, as the other two aren't doing much for me. Not a very impressive starter line up, IMO. None of them really make an "impact" for me. X and Y though have some great looking starters, equal to gen 1 and 2, IMO. That is going to be a hard decision for me, I like all three.