I find the movesets very helpful, and I think the tiers are good, so someone doesn't waltz in with a whole bunch of legendaries when you have UU pokemon. Why do people hate smogon? --- "Nostalgia makes the heart feeble. It is the heart's nemesis." - Trema
It's mostly just ignorant people who barely actually play competitive who hate Smogon. There's literally no reason to hate them. It's just a play style and rule set people choose to adopt. If you don't like it, then you don't have to play that way. And tiers only make the game more fun and creative than the other way around. --- 3DS FC: - White 2 FC: 1765 0547 5604, Name: Kojo
Probably because they are incredibly arrogant. They do a lot of good work for the competitive scene, but ye gods do they have swollen heads, and I suspect people pick up on it and that is where the highly negative views start being formed. --- Official Piplup of the Pokemon X board. Bethesda make poorly made shallow quantity over quality games.
Probably because they are incredibly arrogant. They do a lot of good work for the competitive scene, but ye gods do they have swollen heads, and I suspect people pick up on it and that is where the highly negative views start being formed.
Something along these lines. I tried playing Showdown UU for a couple of days in a row around 7 months ago and just gave up on it because nearly everyone I went up against loved to talk trash whether they were winning or losing horribly. Just constantly spouting off obscenities or criticizing you for making a less than perfect move. I'm not so thin-skinned that I can't handle being given a little crap here and there in competitive games like shooters and MOBAs, but Pokémon is NOT where I go to hear any of that. I'd have never stopped playing if you were able to disable chat or it was at least in a separate box from all of the actual battle information so I could tune it out easier.
I don't hate Smogon itself though. Organizing things the way they do and cleaning up after the actual devs of the game to make sure the competitive playing field is even enough is very admirable and appreciated. I just wish it wasn't needed in the first place.