This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Gamefaqs Favorite Generation 1 Pokemon, Round 2, Battle 25: Charmeleon vs Eevee

#1Samp98518Posted 6/11/2013 8:15:02 PM(edited)
Charmeleon or Eevee? - Results (17 votes)
Charmeleon
41.18% (7 votes)
7
Eevee
58.82% (10 votes)
10
This poll is now closed.
Bracket: http://challonge.com/puiyqiom

Yesterday's Results:
Meowth 11, Ponyta 16
Raticate 6, Dragonair 27

Other Match: Vileplume vs Doduo ( http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/696959-pokemon-x/66431208 )

Tomorrow's Matches: Poliwag vs Bellsprout, Sandslash vs Electrode

Easy choice for me, but I expect a pretty good battle. Charmeleon, as it might be my favorite fire type of them all.
---
Excuse me, sir? Can you sign my bus schedule?
#2ShariadarowPosted 6/11/2013 8:26:56 PM
Not a question for me either. People these days may see Eevee as a little overdone due to it's 8 evolutions, but it's arguably one of, if not THE most unique pokemon for that reason. Considering the pokemon series has such an emphasis on evolution, a pokemon based entirely on that, while also being cute, deserves it's popularity.

Even if we disregard all evolutions past gen 1, it was still very unique due to evolving into one of three. While I like Charmeleon, it along with Quilava and Servine being my favourite starters(up until fennekin, anyway), it's just a starter, and not a very special one at that. Charmander is cuter, and Charizard is more popular even if it's kind of bad, leaving Charmeleon in a position where it simply cant compare to Eevee.