I guess the option to side with the evil team, because then there would be 2 different storylines.
More regions would be nice too, but only if the other one(s) will be new too. It's kinda repetitive and boring to play the same thing again... if I want to play that region I can go back to play that game anyway.
I like new stuff.
I'm a the Luigi master! www.freewebs.com/luigi_player/