I in fact did complete the National Pokedex in Platinum, complete with event legendaries, just a few days before the european BW release. I also completed the BW1 and BW2 local pokedexes, but with the help of WiFi 150 pokemon are nothing. I was honestly surprised when I realized I was done, since I never completed RBY's dex - but that was due to local restrictions. I also completed Crystal's pokedex, except for Celebi. Took quite a while tough, since I only completed it in the GBA era and thus had to figure out myself that GBA hardware doesn't let you trade on GBC games.
I plan on doing it in XY as well. At least the regional dex shouldn't be hard if I just catch everything on every route before moving on. A check list like in BW2 would be really nice.
I did it in B2. I had to trade with a friend for version exclusives from W2. I had the rest of the Pokémon in other games. It went faster than expected, like a week after E4. --- The official Riolu-Master (from Sweden) 3DS FC 5198-2459-7859
Gen I for sure. Maybe Gen II. It was too long ago to remember. --- https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/82442627/Adelle.png I draw lolis :D https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/82442627/IsawaKiyokoAlternate.png
I filled the Gen 4 Dex and transferred everything to Black, then my copy of Black got stolen. Started over and managed to finish it again a couple weeks ago. --- http://i.minus.com/iMiDLgXxPQ0kY.gif http://i.minus.com/iHB1Qp9HBxaNP.gif
I recently finished the National dex in Black 2. I was able to get every pokemon from all of the games I owned, except the Glameow line. I had to trade for it. I find it pretty funny and odd how it worked out like that.
I've done it in Platinum and Black, and am working on Black 2 right now. Should be done with that one in about an hour or so.
I might have got really close in the first couple of generations but was missing some of the event Pokemon. Maybe I even completed them, though I can't remember for sure.
Gen 3 was just a pain in the ass since a lot of the Pokemon needed to be transferred. Props to anyone who actually went through with all that... --- THAT'S MISS FUNERAL CAKE TO YOU i disgust myself and everyone around me