This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Which is the better game? Black/White 2 or X/Y?

  • Topic Archived
This topic contains spoilers - you can click, tap, or highlight to reveal them
  1. Boards
  2. Pokemon X
  3. Which is the better game? Black/White 2 or X/Y?
2 years ago#1
Which is better? - Results (205 votes)
Black/White 2
17.07% (35 votes)
35
X/Y
70.24% (144 votes)
144
I didn't play B/W2
9.27% (19 votes)
19
I didn't play X/Y
1.46% (3 votes)
3
I haven't played either
1.95% (4 votes)
4
This poll is now closed.
Black and White 2 had a pretty awesome story and tons of post game content, plus the easy/hard mode was a cool feature. X and Y seems to take a step back for every step forward. The story was almost nonexistent, and there is barely any post game content. I hope that the next entry is more fulfilling.
---
Official Swinub
3DS Friend Code: 0602-6783-9027 - Friend safari: ICE type: Delibird, Bergmite, Dewgong
2 years ago#2
Even though BW2 was better than XY, X and Y's story wasn't non existent.
2 years ago#3
Thaxagoodname posted...
Even though BW2 was better than XY, X and Y's story wasn't non existent.


What is mega evolution? "Oh it's just cause you get this bracelet and have a bond with pokemon!!"
What is beauty? "Beauty is destroying everyone cause they're not us!!"
That's all I got from the story. The only good part was the old guy with his lost pokemon.

---
Official Swinub
3DS Friend Code: 0602-6783-9027 - Friend safari: ICE type: Delibird, Bergmite, Dewgong
2 years ago#4
Black and White 2's narrative was the RS formula with no attached message. X and Y had heavy messages despite following the same formula. BW2's primary advantage as a game over BW1 was Pokemon availability, and these games had that, too. I see no reason to consider BW2 the better game.
---
Go to Gamestop, buy a Steam card, and use it to purchase Ys Origin. You won't be disappointed.
4227-1617-5338 Safari:Audino/Lillipup/Chansey
2 years ago#5
lazycomplife posted...
Thaxagoodname posted...
Even though BW2 was better than XY, X and Y's story wasn't non existent.


What is mega evolution? "Oh it's just cause you get this bracelet and have a bond with pokemon!!"
What is beauty? "Beauty is destroying everyone cause they're not us!!"
That's all I got from the story. The only good part was the old guy with his lost pokemon.


Then you misunderstood it or missed it entirely. Go talk to the NPCs in the museum and rewatch the major cutscenes. There's heavy stuff here.
---
Go to Gamestop, buy a Steam card, and use it to purchase Ys Origin. You won't be disappointed.
4227-1617-5338 Safari:Audino/Lillipup/Chansey
2 years ago#6
whats better a corolla or a ferrari?
---
Pokemon X is gonna be dope
2 years ago#7
Black 2 and White 2 had great post game content but XY does everything better for the most part. I imagine we'll have something with an equally good or better post game by the end of this gen.
---
Blah.
2 years ago#8
zinformant posted...
Black and White 2's narrative was the RS formula with no attached message. X and Y had heavy messages despite following the same formula. BW2's primary advantage as a game over BW1 was Pokemon availability, and these games had that, too. I see no reason to consider BW2 the better game.


At least N was someone you could relate to.
---
Official Swinub
3DS Friend Code: 0602-6783-9027 - Friend safari: ICE type: Delibird, Bergmite, Dewgong
2 years ago#9
lazycomplife posted...
zinformant posted...
Black and White 2's narrative was the RS formula with no attached message. X and Y had heavy messages despite following the same formula. BW2's primary advantage as a game over BW1 was Pokemon availability, and these games had that, too. I see no reason to consider BW2 the better game.


At least N was someone you could relate to.


As a person who was raised by wolves, I can agree with this.
---
The best dressed person on the Pokemon X and Y board!
My FABULOUS Friend Code: 1719-3885-3128.
2 years ago#10
Wouldn't it be more reasonable to compare BW to XY? You are comparing a remake/sequel to a first game afterall.
---
3DS FC: 2723-9024-7215 "Nothing ventured, nothing gained"
"The good times of today, are the sad thoughts of tomorrow."
  1. Boards
  2. Pokemon X
  3. Which is the better game? Black/White 2 or X/Y?

Report Message

Terms of Use Violations:

Etiquette Issues:

Notes (optional; required for "Other"):
Add user to Ignore List after reporting

Topic Sticky

You are not allowed to request a sticky.

  • Topic Archived