This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Decided to vote on every single Pokemon based on how much I liked them

#1mjalal100Posted 10/24/2013 3:14:35 AM
I made a spreadsheet of all 718 currently known Pokemon and ranked each one on a subjective 1-10 of how much I liked them. My results..

Kanto Average- 5.89
Johto Average- 5.99
Hoenn Average- 6.21
Sinnoh Average- 6.21
Unova Average- 5.88
Kalos Average- 6.72

I find it interesting how I seem to think that the Pokemon remained pretty consistent in quality, with a significant spike for the most recent generation!

If you want to try it for yourself, I have a google doc template at You can download it as excel and fill it in, and the averages should happen as you're doing it. It does take a while though! I used to look at sprites.

I would have done Megaevolutions but I worry that it could skew the results (as they honestly all look pretty awesome), so I didn't include them.
If I had a superpower, it would be the ability to defy logic.
#2slmcknettPosted 10/24/2013 3:18:02 AM
Darn, I don't have Excel on this computer. :(
And this seems really fun.
Kari Wahlgren: "Guys, I just can't wrap my mouth around it."
#3matt-nicklinPosted 10/24/2013 3:19:41 AM
slmcknett posted...
Darn, I don't have Excel on this computer. :(
And this seems really fun.

Fun? I'd rather read the iTunes user agreement.
3DS FC: 4253-3827-3643 (Pansear, Larvesta, Braixen)
PM if adding me
#4JakeisaLiePosted 10/24/2013 4:09:26 AM
I have way too much time on my hands...

Kanto: ~6.19
Johto: 6.34
Hoenn: ~6.6
Sinnoh: ~6.53
Unova: ~5.99
Kalos: ~6.71

odd, I wasn't really expecting Kalos to come out on top
#5NegaZeldaPosted 10/24/2013 4:44:28 AM(edited)
I think I might have been a bit too critical...

Kanto: 5.52
Johto: 4.75
Hoenn: 5.82
Sinnoh: 5.33
Unova: 5.07
Kalos: 5.43

But the order's about right with maybe Kanto = Kalos rather than above it.
If life gives you lemons, sell 'em to Tom Nook.
Black 2 FC: 0132-9980-0476, 3DS FC: 5284-2520-2972 (Pokemon IGN: Aki)
#6The_DragonwPosted 10/24/2013 4:48:01 AM
How do you save the sheet? My page has no save option.
3DS Friend Code: 1950 8577 8687
The official Super Corrupt Shadow Lugia of the Pokemon X/Y boards
#7fuzi11Posted 10/24/2013 4:56:28 AM
I did something like that once, but only on a scale of 1 to 5

1: stupid
2: meh
3: indifferent
4: good
5: love it

I don't no the numbers anymore but I can tell you it looked like that


Although 5 was a bit tricky as 5 had a lot of Pokemon I really disliked and a lot of Pokemon that I truly love.

4 on the other hand is filled with lots and lots of meh. (although now that I raise a Togepi, Togekiss has jumped from meh to indifferent. I still don't like its design, but I sort of got attached to my Prii)

I have to properly redo the list though, with Kalosmons of course
#8SharwenPosted 10/24/2013 5:29:26 AM
I was a little harsh, I think..

Kanto Average: 4.774834437
Johto Average: 4.5
Hoenn Average: 4.82962963
Sinnoh Average: 4.196261682
Unova Average: 3.658064516
Kalos Average: 4.753623188
#9fuzi11Posted 10/24/2013 6:11:24 AM
Kanto Average 7,649006623
Johto Average 6,39
Hoenn Average 6,676470588
Sinnoh Average 5,869158879
Unova Average 7,057692308
Kalos Average 7,898550725

oha, if we go by my newest numbers it looks like


whoa... who would have thought. It's probably the low amount of pokes in gen 6, and none of them (except Espurr) look bad to me (and espurr doesn't really look bad, just strange with a very monotone colouring)

in general the worst ratings got pretty much every fishmon
and looking at my list my top disliked pokemon (with a rating of 1) are