This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Rate the Game: Pokemon Red/Blue

#1XaltheronPosted 1/3/2014 9:22:48 PM
How would you rate Red and Blue? - Results (106 votes)
1/10
8.49% (9 votes)
9
2/10
3.77% (4 votes)
4
3/10
5.66% (6 votes)
6
4/10
3.77% (4 votes)
4
5/10
3.77% (4 votes)
4
6/10
6.6% (7 votes)
7
7/10
16.98% (18 votes)
18
8/10
12.26% (13 votes)
13
9/10
7.55% (8 votes)
8
10/10
31.13% (33 votes)
33
This poll is now closed.
So I figured that rather than doing a simple Your Favourite Game poll, we'd get a more detailed and accurate result by rating each game individually and then comparing the results to see how they stack.

First up are the games that started it all, Red and Blue. How would you rate these games compared to the rest of the series? An ageless classic or an unplayable mess?

Also bear in mind that this is for the original versions only, there will be a seperate poll for FireRed/LeafGreen.
#2Inferno4501Posted 1/3/2014 9:24:13 PM
I never played it so...
---
"They don't call me the Inferno for nothing..." *Trips over a rock then bursts into flames for no reason* 3DS Friend Code: 2492-5028-5347
#3ZerohFaultPosted 1/3/2014 9:28:32 PM
Nostalgia: 9/10

Actual Gameplay/Graphics/ETC: 4/10
---
Am I the most hated person in these boards?
Or is it still PTT? ;)
#4pikabyPosted 1/3/2014 9:39:22 PM
In 1996, 8/10

In 2014, 3/10
#5b619pokePosted 1/5/2014 11:03:09 PM
I give it a 1 out of 10 cuz i neer played it. I think it is a terrible pokemon game. I mean when x and y came came out what if it was black and white only had 151 pokemon in it and you had to battle and trade via a cord. What would u rate the game then cuz thats exactly what red and blue is.
#6jasonjskPosted 1/5/2014 11:09:07 PM
Even though they were just the bare bones (sexy bare bones, that is) of Pokemon, the psychic type SLAY (think: mewtwo + amnesia) is the best thing that ever happened to pokemon
---
1950-8977-8867 is my FC. I have Teddiursa, Ditto and Loudred for my Safari. bored bc pokebank got delayed.. so anyone add me! (pm me for an add)
#7reyray0709Posted 1/5/2014 11:11:20 PM
Lol10/10Nostalgia

Solid 6 or 7.
---
Umvc3 Team: Zero, Vergil, Wesker - Street fighter 3 & 4: Yun - Injustice: Nightwing & Batman.
PSN & GT: reyray0709. 3DS Friend code 3110-5005-0804
#8legitgamer405Posted 1/5/2014 11:14:16 PM
1/10 because

http://www.ign.com/boards/threads/pokemon-has-so-much-bull-in-gen-1-i-lol-whenever-someone-says-it-was-the-best.452601714/


I'm referring to the picture btw. :p
---
Official Arceus and (Mega)Lucario of the Pokemon X/Y boards!
#9Emeraldsonic101Posted 1/5/2014 11:14:56 PM
jasonjsk posted...
Even though they were just the bare bones (sexy bare bones, that is) of Pokemon, the psychic type SLAY (think: mewtwo + amnesia) is the best thing that ever happened to pokemon


This. It is also why I just love the psychic type. Such great games, albeit broken due to the lack of separation in the Special stat.
---
Not changing this sig until 3D Classics Q*Bert is released! Spread the word! Started 7-1-11
3DS friend code: 4253-3480-2588
#10FuneralCakePosted 1/5/2014 11:16:18 PM
Probably 6. It was fun back then, but I wasn't really being objective enough to see its flaws.

It's still not a terrible game, given that it was made in 1996. Still, it's nowhere near perfect. Just decent.
---
YOU WANT SOME FUNERAL TO GO WITH THAT CAKE?
| 3DS FC: 3437 - 4335 - 3104 | | Friend Safari: Panpour, Wartortle, Frogadier |