I dont know if its creepy, but i know somethign i find entirely unnerving. In HG/SS if you have an arceus, you can choose to get one of the Creation Trio. You bring arceus to a certain place, and then suddenly, and with absolutely no warning... This happens
And no one ever speaks of it. Didn't see that one coming.
Mr. Bonding after seeing the theory of him being a rapist. Charmander's Gen 1 sprite, them eyes look like empty eye-sockets to me... (O.O') Actually lot's of sprites kinda scare me...like Haunter, i just can't handle that zig-zag teeth/fang pattern for some reason...creeps me out..
Can't think of anything else atm
ADD: Actually i had a "revese creep" with the Lavender Town theme: I love it in Gen1, but hearing how they had completely butchered it in the remakes really creeped my out.
Strip the flesh! Salt the wounds! *Manical laughter*