So is Mario Kart 64 generally considered the worst Mario Kart?

#1EternalNetherPosted 4/15/2014 7:22:48 PM
Not to say any of them are bad. And they all have at least one flaw, such as the lack of balance in Mario Kart Wii, the missing modes and characters in 7, etc. But most people seem to regard Mario Kart 64 as the worst, and Double Dash, Wii, and 7 as the best.

And looking back I can kind of see that. I grew up on Mario Kart 64 (got back to SNES version later) and idolized the game as a child. When I went back to play it on the virtual console later down the road though, I found it pretty intolerable. I think a lot of that has to do with how slow the game feels compared to all the others. Tracks are long, with very little going on. Karts feel slow, every time you hit a shell and flip up into the air it takes forever for you to get back to the race. The animation for things like that took too much time. I'd fault it for the character selection, but the game was old and that was to be expected.

So is that it, or do people hate it for different reasons?
Steam ID/PSN ID: Solirus
Currently Playing:Infamous Second Son (PS4), FFX/X-2 HD (PS3),
#2Austin_4ePosted 4/15/2014 7:25:01 PM
Super Mario Kart aged the worst, anyone saying otherwise has terribly thick nostalgia glasses.

That aside, Super Circuit was easily the worst on top of having WAY too many repeat tracks and like fifty damn Bowser Castle tracks (exaggeration sure, but seriously).
--- | |
[[ PSN / WiiU / Steam: Austin_4e ]]
#3BabyLuigiOnFirePosted 4/15/2014 7:25:42 PM
I personally think it's the worst Mario Kart. Some people think it's a better entry because of nostalgia and how much it was a blast to play the game.

No, Super Circuit is still considered the worst Mario Kart even though I disagree strongly with the notion.
I'm a girl who loves Baby Luigi and accepted him as my personal lord and savior.
Your local Wario sadist.
#4pikachu936Posted 4/15/2014 7:34:00 PM
Played MK64 last week, I still find it more enjoyable than SMK.
(>-'.'-)> 2 Kirbies went into a food store, the next day the store went bankrupt. <(-'.'-<)
David Mitchell > You.
#5GeneraLightPosted 4/15/2014 8:07:05 PM
SMK is objectively the worst. Take the nostalgia goggles off.
#6barrabaCHHSPosted 4/15/2014 8:08:10 PM
Nope, I would say MK64 is overrated.
Appreciate Rob
Poor underrated fella, he was my main in MKDS, a main in Brawl and will be a main in Smash 4.
#7Rad_DudesmanPosted 4/15/2014 8:10:37 PM
Mario Kart 64 may have aged horribly, but it's still better than SMK.
Nintendo Network ID: raddudesman
Not changing this signature until Blaze the Cat is playable in another Sonic game.
#8MotiJrPosted 4/15/2014 8:18:56 PM
I thought Wii was the worst. Had the worst rubber banding and just was frustrating to play.
I am the voice of reason. I'm also having fun so don't get upset and just have a laugh :D
#9Milla_MaxwellPosted 4/15/2014 8:20:17 PM
MotiJr posted...
I thought Wii was the worst. Had the worst rubber banding and just was frustrating to play.

You're factually wrong if you think Wii had worse rubber banding then 64.
People who want Havic101 to re-accept my friend request on GameFAQs: 21
#10123chattyPosted 4/15/2014 8:42:22 PM(edited)
SMK is definitely the worst, and might just be the poster game for early installment weirdness. I'd say MK64 is number 2, but for some reason everyone loves to hate on Super Circuit even though it improved a lot of things I didn't like about 64 (wonky physics) at the cost of slightly worse tracks that are still pretty good. In my eyes, 64 is kinda overrated (luckily not on this board, but you'd be surprised at how many people say that it's the best)