I've played that one several times. Easy as pie is right but I do not remember it paying out nearly that much. The sticky shows it paying out $11,500 and 3,600 RP.
Does the sticky list initial cash, or repeat attempts? I can't remember what exactly I got for it, pretty sure it was atleast 20,000. Today was the first time I've ever seen that mission as well, my friend got it while requesting jobs from Martin.