The biggest difference I found between the score on the site and my personal opinion would have to be MAG (77.75%). It is easily my favorite shooter of all time, and I found it to be nearly flawless in my 300ish hours playing. 9.8/10.
I was with you initially until....that. Almost every word is just....wrong.
"HE are genius, firstly." - ASlaveObeys http://i.imgur.com/SQAc17B.png