This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Is the Dell U2412m panel as good as...

#1jordandrakoPosted 9/12/2013 8:56:39 AM
I'm going to school for graphic design. I work mainly on PC and I hate apple, not to say I don't know how/won't use a Mac, but I hate them as a company. I use my crappy Samsung laptop over their iMacs every day; however, I can't deny dat color quality.
Does the Dell U2412m or ASUS PA248Q (supposedly same panel) have a color gamut and display that can get even close to apple's displays?
---
i5-3570k @ 4.0Ghz | Gigabyte GTX670 | M4 128GB SSD | 2.5TB HDD | DDR3 1600 8GB | 520W
http://imgur.com/a/uSBwE
#2aak57Posted 9/12/2013 8:58:56 AM
If you're going into graphic design, seems like you should get a full-gamut monitor. U2412M is not such a monitor. I dunno if they discontinued it, but its cousin the U2410 is full-gamut.
---
http://i.imgur.com/ULj4q.jpg
Let strength be granted, so the world might be mended.
#3jordandrako(Topic Creator)Posted 9/12/2013 9:05:26 AM
aak57 posted...
If you're going into graphic design, seems like you should get a full-gamut monitor. U2412M is not such a monitor. I dunno if they discontinued it, but its cousin the U2410 is full-gamut.


Thanks for the suggestion. But I should have put a budget on that. Keywords: going to school.
I'm not rich yet so the $600 u2410 is about $200 over my budget for now.
---
http://zengraphics.webatu.com
#4animanganimePosted 9/12/2013 9:15:30 AM
If you are doing Photography then you might want a full-gamut monitor
But if you are doing Graphics Design, any IPS would do, even though it does not display all the colors in the world but at least it is 8 bit and not 6 bit + dithering like TN
You will have to match whatever color you use on your design to the limited set of pantone colors anyway so again any IPS should display those just fine and some more.
Oh, get a calibrator too
---
WC i5 2500k @ 4.4 ghz, 2x GTX 670 DirectCU II, Samsung 830 128GB SSD, 16GB G.Skill 1600 DDR3, Zalman 1000W PSU, Cosmos 1000 Case, HP LP3065 @ 2560 x 1600 IPS
#5ShubPosted 9/12/2013 9:19:03 AM
As far as I know, the iMac uses 8-bit displays, so the color depth is less than something like an U2413 (which has replaced the U2410). The U2412M would have the same color depth as the iMac.
---
-What is best in life?
-To crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and to hear the lamentation of the women.
#6jordandrako(Topic Creator)Posted 9/12/2013 9:25:58 AM
I'm definitely not a photographer. Stock photos and creative commons licensed pics are going to be my main source. I know sRGB covers most of the Pantone gamut, so thats why I'm willing to go with the ASUS PA248Q for now. At least until I can afford a 10-bit monitor. Any other monitors that might be better than one in the $400 budget?
I do plan on getting a Spyder4pro as well (unless you have suggestions on better calibrators too).
---
http://zengraphics.webatu.com
#7jordandrako(Topic Creator)Posted 9/12/2013 9:36:26 AM
Not sure if this is accurate, but this link http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1708553
says that the u2412m is 6-bit, the PA248q is 8-bit and on par with the u2410. I know the QC on the ASUS isn't quite as good so I might get backlight bleeding, but since I'm ordering the throught amazon, I can just get a replacement if that rare problem happens to me.
---
http://zengraphics.webatu.com
#8animanganimePosted 9/12/2013 9:42:10 AM(edited)
One of the reasons why the iMac/rMBP screens look so impressive is because the don't have an anti-glare coating on top, it will be more reflective yes but it is also crystal clear. If you really want that clarity then I would recommend a glossy IPS instead of that Asus.

This is the reason I will never be using anything with anti-glare again
http://www.overclock.net/content/type/61/id/954440/width/563/height/429

I am using the X-rite i1 to calibrate my monitor, no experience with any Spyder whatsoever but from what I have heard you will be fine with either.
---
WC i5 2500k @ 4.4 ghz, 2x GTX 670 DirectCU II, Samsung 830 128GB SSD, 16GB G.Skill 1600 DDR3, Zalman 1000W PSU, Cosmos 1000 Case, HP LP3065 @ 2560 x 1600 IPS
#9UberLurkerPosted 9/12/2013 10:17:01 AM
I have an Asus PA248Q and absolutely love it, no stuck pixels and the factory calibration was pretty good right out of the box. Granted, although I consider myself an amateur photographer, I don't have a legitimate need for 100% accurate color and wide gamut... but I do try to get as close as I can to true life.

You may want to consult the reviews here:

http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/articles/icc_profiles.htm#the_database

These guys are exhaustive in their monitor evaluations and I think they have both of the monitors you're looking at covered. FWIW they're both quite comparable in ability with the Dell being better at some aspects but the Asus better in a few others... it's pretty much a wash IMHO.

Either way you should give it a look before pulling the trigger.
#10WerdnAndreWPosted 9/12/2013 10:48:03 AM
UberLurker posted...
I have an Asus PA248Q and absolutely love it, no stuck pixels and the factory calibration was pretty good right out of the box.


How long have you had your monitor and do you have any problems when using DVI? Seems like a common problem for the DVI port to flicker which mine does.
---
Corsair 500r ~ P8Z68-V Pro ~ i5 2500k ~ Hyper 212+ ~ Corsair 2x4gb ~ TX750w v2 ~ 560 Ti ~ F3 1TB ~ Crucial M4 128GB ~ Xonar DG ~ Tt Meka G1 ~ Asus PA248Q