I always liked the second one, but ACF was really good too. I wasn't a big fan of 4. Aside from not being in the Wild West meets fantasy world I love so much, the entire game reeked of corn. That said, the hex system was kinda cool, though personally I preffer the ACF anf WA3 combat system, even if it is outdated. It just felt right for the series. Haven't played 5 yet though. Gotta work on that. I should also pick up the original off the Playstation store, since it's 6 bucks and I can't find ACF anywhere.