First off is fallout 3. I rented it and found the game really boring so I returned it after 5a days without a second later. A year down the road I found it used for like $10. I figured that at that price I could nt go wrong. So I popped it in and could NOT put it down. Picked up new Vegas on release and curse obsidian for not testing their games better.
Another game would be mass effect. The gun play was just sp bad that i could not enjoy playing another second of it. After a two more tries, the game finally stuck and I consider it a pretty darn good game.
"Step 1: Crawl inside. Step 2: The screws go tight, all around. Cross my heart and hope to die. Stick a needle in your eye"