Same person apparently gave Max Payne 3 55/100. That game seemed to have turned out alright.
Sounds about right.
Max Payne 3 SP is basically this: Over ten-minute cutscenes in-between, walked down an alley, watched another cutscene, climbed some stairs, watched another cutscene, walked up an alley, watched another cutscene, continued up the alley, and then watched another cutscene.
On top of that, the game featured no less than five shooting gallery sections, where Max couldn't move, but had to shoot at people who walked into his frame of vision. A 55/100 is somewhat generous.
Seriously game developer/producer please friggin STOP with all the hand-pulling cutscenes and trying to appeal to "kiddie generation" CoD gamers. Not everyone wants all their game to be an interactive QTE movie, doing so is insulting and not nice at all.