The agreement on the music and graphics, story is there. The disagreement I've read comes from other aspects of the game. We don't want Nier to be some groundbreaking 10 out 10. But the flaws mentioned are flaws that could have been fixed. I guess you could try to put it in the niche category but I don't know.... --- "I live my life 3 videogames at a time. Nothing else matters. Not the mortgage, not my clan and their BS. For those 3 games or less, I'm free."