If you liked Prey for those reasons, you might want to try clive Barker's Jericho, TC. Now, there was a reason that game had terrible reviews, but if you like games with an old-school vibe and creepy atmosphere that one will do it for you. .
Yes, that is a great recommendation
Under a cold October sky, I wait Number of deer shot this year: 2
What used to creep you out may not do the trick anymore because "been there done that" syndrome sets in.
Heck, there are times I go back to movies that creeped the hell out of me when I was younger and think "What the hell was wrong with me back then?!?"
Back in 1989 the movie "Communion" scared the crap out of me. I watched it a couple years back and laughed my ass off. I remembered it being a heluva lot scarier, but I was also 20-some years younger too.
~I was stomping goombas and saving princesses long before most of you were born.