I'll help, I 'spose. A couple of my faves: Deadly Premonition Halo series The Walking Dead Mass Effect 1-3 (2 in particular) Red Dead Redemption Fable 1-3 (The whackyness of the sidequests is appealing and fresh, too) Dragon Age Origins Alan Wake
Mass Effect Trilogy Dragon Age Origins Star Wars KOTOR 1, 2 Jade Empire Bioshock Halo Series Max Payne 1, 2, 3 Persona 3, 4 Some Final Fantasy's Read Dead Redemption The Walking Dead MGS1-4 Yakuza 1-4 The Witcher 1, 2 Suikoden I, II, III, V
The list goes on for great stories in video games.
"I have two rules I follow. The first, never kill someone without a reason. The second, you can always find a reason to kill someone." - Saren
Ok I was joking but seriously the best you could come up with is Bioshock( love the game but not top 10 material) and a game based off an anime?
You were joking about asking whether I was joking or not? Okay then... Anyway, Steins;Gate is not based on the anime, the anime was based on the game. Also, I put Bioshock because it is the only exclusive(former) game on Xbox 360, that I remembered, with an above average story.
Call of Duty Battlefiel...
Oh...you said WITH a story
Those have stories...they're just really mediocre and not something that really sticks with you.