last of us god of war 3 uncharted 2 uncharted 3 heavy rain infamous infamous 2 metal gear 4 killzone 3 batman arkham asylum batman city Ni No kuni Skyrim Bioshock 2 Bioshock infinite mass effect 1 mass effect 2 red dead redemption Assassin's Creed 2 orange box mario galaxy 2 journey
LBP 1 LBP 2 Call of Duty MLB THE SHOW
Honarable mentions: Dead Space & Twilight Princess
Assassin's Creed II Beautiful Katamari Bioshock Brutal Legend Catherine Dark Souls Dragon Age: Origins Eternal Sonata Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved Kameo: Elements of Power Limbo Lost Odyssey MagnaCarta II Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots NiER No More Heroes: Heroes' Paradise Persona 4 Arena Portal 2 Resonance of Fate Rock Band 2 Tales of Vesperia Tekken Tag Tournament 2 THE iDOLM@STER Tomb Raider 2013 Valkyria Chronicles
I'm expecting Killer Is Dead, Watch Dogs, and Lightning Returns to take spots on this list by the time we're through. --- "In peace, vigilance. In war, victory. In death, sacrifice." ~ The Grey Wardens http://www.trueachievements.com/mygames.aspx?gamerid=71900
Uncharted 1 had a better story then 2, 2 was still good but not as good as 1! Oblivion was better then Skyrim! Saint's Row 1 was better the 2, but thank god you did not put 3 in! COD 2 was far better then Call of Duty: World at War and COD 3!
Killzone 2, Tomb Raider, Mass Effect 2 (1 yes, 2 & 3 no), and Mafia II are NOT the best games of the gen! I don't know about Max Payne 3, I've never played it!
Some good ones that should be there are Fallout 3, Oblivion, Deadly Premonition (ok, it was made last gen, but only came out this gen), Minecraft, Metro 2033, Portal 2, and Dead Island!
Wasn't easy and would probably change a little if you asked me another day, but here it is in no particular order:
Torchlight 2 Metro 2033 Far Cry 3 Blood Dragon Sonic and Sega All Stars Racing Transformed Recettear: An Item Shop's Tale Just Cause 2 Dark Souls The Last Story Kirby's Return to Dreamland Little Big Planet 2 Bayonetta(on 360) Path of Exile Mario Galaxy 2 Dustforce Sin and Punishment 2: Star Successor Xenoblade Saints Row 3 Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance Fallout New Vegas Dishonored Jamestown: Legend of the Lost Colony Mark of the Ninja Strike Suit Zero Sonic Generations Monster Hunter Tri --- Warning: My opinions are mod-able.