This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Rate the Game Day 1: L.A. Noire

#1horror_spookyPosted 9/12/2013 12:45:00 PM
On a scale of 1 to 10... - Results (149 votes)
1
4.7% (7 votes)
7
2
0.67% (1 votes)
1
3
3.36% (5 votes)
5
4
2.68% (4 votes)
4
5
5.37% (8 votes)
8
6
8.72% (13 votes)
13
7
23.49% (35 votes)
35
8
30.2% (45 votes)
45
9
12.75% (19 votes)
19
10
8.05% (12 votes)
12
This poll is now closed.
10 obviously is the highest, 1 is the lowest

Will take recommendations for future topics.
---
Just when they think they got the answers, I change the questions..
www.cheatmasters.com
#2simonbelmont2Posted 9/12/2013 12:45:49 PM
7/10
---
and when he crossed the bridge the phantoms came to meet him
#3orangeneePosted 9/12/2013 12:53:53 PM
7/10

-1 for lousy AI drivers

-1 for a horribly flawed interrogation mechanic

-1 for all the 'you don't understand noir' posts
---
How to divide by Zero: Find person named Zero, get him/her to divide something.
GT/PSN:Hellsteeth30
#4Seanie1200Posted 9/12/2013 12:59:39 PM
I voted 6. The game was a great idea but it got too samey too quickly. There wasn't enough to see or do in thw world and the questioning of suspects seemed too random. Many a time I questioned, got things wrong, reloaded and got the same reactions with different approaches.

Also I seem to remember pieces of evidence only turning up if oyu did certain things. On one case I searched an alley and found nothing but after I questioned someone a knife appeared in a dustbin. It spoiled the immersion for me.
#5glassghost0Posted 9/12/2013 1:04:35 PM
9/10

Very enjoyable experience, I understand the hate it gets, and can see why some find it boring.

Overall, I had a great time with it though. Wish we had gotten more DLC cases

Hope to see a sequel one day, I think Rockstar has hinted at wanting to do one
---
No Thanks
3DS FC: 3067-4989-8122
#6orangeneePosted 9/12/2013 1:11:05 PM
glassghost0 posted...
9/10

Very enjoyable experience, I understand the hate it gets, and can see why some find it boring.

Overall, I had a great time with it though. Wish we had gotten more DLC cases

Hope to see a sequel one day, I think Rockstar has hinted at wanting to do one


If we only we got burglary and fraud desks, if a sequel transpired those need to be in it.
---
How to divide by Zero: Find person named Zero, get him/her to divide something.
GT/PSN:Hellsteeth30
#7656stoogePosted 9/12/2013 1:11:05 PM
Seanie1200 posted...
I voted 6. The game was a great idea but it got too samey too quickly. There wasn't enough to see or do in thw world and the questioning of suspects seemed too random. Many a time I questioned, got things wrong, reloaded and got the same reactions with different approaches.

Also I seem to remember pieces of evidence only turning up if oyu did certain things. On one case I searched an alley and found nothing but after I questioned someone a knife appeared in a dustbin. It spoiled the immersion for me.


That. Almost word for word. Really wanted to enjoy it, but it just seemed like trial and error rather than an organic system.

I never came close to finishing it though, so I might go back one day and give it another shot.
---
For want of the price of tea and a slice, the old man died.
#8scoobydoobydontPosted 9/12/2013 1:21:20 PM
10/10. Beat it 100% three times, still love it. I would be okay with literally every cop, detective, lawyer, medical, etc procedural tv show being cancelled and resumed in an interactive LA Noire format. I would love if Telltale ditched the weird cartoon/comic look they go with nowadays and licensed the engine too (Yes, I know TWD is based on the comic, I don't care).
---
"I don't hate people, I just feel better when they're not around." - Charles Bukowski
http://i.imgur.com/mRh5ifp.png
#9grimmdaddyPosted 9/12/2013 1:23:17 PM
9/10

I really enjoyed what they were going for and the pacing was pretty good
#10Pacman2dxPosted 9/12/2013 1:24:07 PM
Great game but outside of the investigations there's not much to do. They should have spent a bit more time creating scenarios outside the investigations - though the random crimes were cool, there wasn't enough of them.
---
Shingeki No Kyojin | Attack On Titan
Are you willing to give your beating heart for humanity?