Well let's see, the only good JRPGs I've played in this generation have been Lost Odyssey and Xenoblade Chronicles. Both of them have been received positively. Everything else has been crap or mediocre at best and has been received negatively. Dat logic.
Most get pretty damn good reviews across the board. Only the uber bad ones get the bad reviews across the board.
dq vi, radiant historia,pokemon black white, tactics ogre psp, recoded, disgaea 4,xenoblade, last story, inazuma eleven 1 ( european reviews), solorobo ( european reviews) ect all got mostly good reviews. Games like WKC 2 did not because the game stunk.
Even famitsu which is largely regarded as the most respected review source in japan has given fantastic scores.
Unfortunately most of the time only negative stuff only gets posted so thats all people think there is.
Games to Watch: Final Fantasy 13-2,Ninokuni PS3,Persona 5,SRW OG 2,Dragon Quest X,Kingdom Hearts DDD, Paper Mario 3ds,7th dragon 2020, Digimon World Re:D