Confirm. RDR is by FAR my favorite game this gen.. hell, it's one of my favorite games ever. I still play both the 360 and PS3 versions of RDR all the time, both single player and online. I just love everything about that game. Setting, visuals, locations, story, characters.. great multiplayer, awesome DLC with Undead Nightmare. Just and amazing amazing game. -
I'm afraid it was probably the most boring game I've played this gen.
Took me half an hour to travel between missions, which only lasted about 5 minutes each. Shootouts, duels and cattle-herding were fun but there just wasn't enough of them. I also thought John Marston was boring, and incredibly clichéd. There were plenty of technically good aspects about the game but I didn't have much fun with it.