Red Dead Redemption. Outstanding display of how a game should be made. Wonderful story, graphics, characters, plenty of things to do, great gameplay and DLC that makes you want to play it (Undead Nightmare, online Poker and Liar's Dice). I'm not too sold on the multiplayer, but the single player is so good I just ignore it (aside from the online gambling DLC).
Metal Gear Solid takes the #1 spot of my all time favourite games, but RDR follows behind at #2.
Couldn't have said it any better.
Insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results - AE
My brain shuts down when presented with these kinds of questions and I don't even make the time to choose "top X game for X platform or X generation or of all time because I'm always busy or playing a game.
Guess I don't have an answer. Doesn't help that I always have a new game rented in and out.
I do benefits for all religions. I'd hate to blow the hereafter on a technicality. - Bob Hope I'm right about everything, every time. 60% of the time.