Kentaro21 posted...For me, it would be Psychonauts. The voice acting was great, the gameplay was unique, the humor always made me laugh a little, and the story was a lot more deep than you'd think. Though, in recent years, I've seen it pick up steam.
This, this, this so very much. Everything about Psychonauts is just so perfect. It can be a collectathon if you want it to be, but most of it is optional. Meanwhile you do some awesome platforming and puzzle solving across such diverse level themes. And the humor, need I say more than the Milk Man?! Those very few lines he utters are the best lines in the entire game.
gamemaster712 posted...Deadly premonition
God hand
I agree with those, but I think God Hand has been making a comeback, increbily*. And Deadly Premonition is actually pretty scary from what I've seen, and has such great dialogue like Psychonauts. The game is pretty nice, and I don't have to think twice, so says Mr. Stewart.
* - The misspelling of "incredibly" in IGN's Godhand review, which has still not been fixed to this day.
Okami
Whoa, really? Okami was underrated? I played through and beat that not to long ago, and found it to be a pretty amazing game. It has its problems (which are pretty glaring, but still passable), but it is one hell of a game.
---
You know that game I never played? That one?
10/10, GoTY and Best (insert genre here).