Aside from some slow down every now and again, QC is one of the best PSN games I've ever played. Dare I say it's even much better than Portal.
I beat it last week, and I strongly disagree with your opinion.
The story wasn't really there, which was one of the best things about portal.
The "god" character (uncle) was not funny more than 2 or 3 times. It felt like gladOS on a 20$ budget.
However, I really enjoyed some of the puzzles (couch surfing ftw), and a few of them very really clever.
It did just feel like a cheap portal imitation to me though. And the ending was just utterly terrible. I thought they were building it up to something awesome, but nope
I'd give it 6.5-7/10
The reason it probably felt like a portal rip off is because it was designed by the chick who was lead designer on Portal and Narbacular Drop. --- I can't stand from falling down, I'm too sick to throw up Everyone keeps talking and they can't shut the f*** up
Minus points for lack of puzzles, forgettable soundtrack, poorly developed side characters and average multiplayer. Everything else was excellent. --- PSN: lady_mystic Mind your blasted manners! Uncivil, uncouth, uncultivated! - Lady Smith