Because not everyone loves the game he loves as much as he does and people are giving more love to a game he doesn't like as much.
These kinds of things bug people. Everyone must love and hate everything in the exact same manner as they do otherwise they get confused by the world around them. --- Sony PS4 Conference = http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x5SVJw4ZcJY
Tomb Raider has way better graphics, presentation, and far FAR better combat and general gameplay. The story also makes sense.
That is some funny stuff right there. I haven't even played Bioshock infinite and I know that game is better in those two aspects.
Edit- Oh and the story in Tomb Raider is rubbish. When a story has such a blatant plot device as Dr. James Whitman that people who don't even know what a plot device is knows he is a plot device your story sucks. --- http://psnprofiles.com/kingofall214