Awesome game. The game-play is somewhat a jack of all trades, and ends up being somewhat mediocre...but the story, characters, voice-acting, and presentation put it over the top. But that's just my opinion.
It is still a 5/5 game for me. The story was very solid and I enjoyed the brutal stealth gameplay. The multiplayer also turned out to be a lot more fun than I expected. When i clear up my backlog a bit I'm definitely going to play the game again. The Last of Us was the first game in awhile that made me anxious to play it whenever I could.
Check out what I'm playing this week at: http://www.gamesmelter.com/what-im-playing-this-week-12/
Still an excellent story, with a thought provoking and ambiguous ending. But the gameplay was mediocre and the MP has got to be the biggest fail for a tacked-on MP there is. See ME3 for a good and proper tacked-on MP. Also hardly any replay-ability.