This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Uncharted 2: Among thieves vs Tomb Raider Reboot?

#31blackerfire_Posted 8/27/2014 8:52:02 PM
Oystersoup posted...
Uncharted 2 by far.

This. TR just felt like it was trying too hard to be an Uncharted clone that didn't really bring anything new to the table. I enjoyed the game, but that's what I thought almost the entire time I was playing it.

I do hope future TR games will go back to the series' roots in terms of level and puzzle design (expanding the environments and bumping up the difficulty).
#32Legend524Posted 8/27/2014 10:08:56 PM
So..why was the new tomb raider pit against the best uncharted and not uncharted 1?
#33BillysanPosted 8/27/2014 10:48:59 PM
Legend524 posted...
So..why was the new tomb raider pit against the best uncharted and not uncharted 1?


It came out in the first year or so of PS3 and features more dated mechanics because of that. So it's an unfair comparison.
---
http://billysan291.deviantart.com/
PSN: Billysan291 3DS FC:4914-2847-6766
#34Legend524Posted 8/27/2014 11:29:14 PM
By that logic..why not use uncharted 3?

I can also say that tomb raider is re introducing Lara and should be compared to the original uncharted, which introduced drake
#35darkness1018Posted 8/28/2014 12:22:14 AM
I really liked the TR reboot, its me fav TR game ever but I gotta go with Uncharted 2. I just liked the characters, story & settings more.
---
PSN: nightwing2099 GT: Gambit1018
Systems I own: PS3, PS4, PSP, Original Xbox, XB1
#36BillysanPosted 8/28/2014 1:09:17 AM
Legend524 posted...
By that logic..why not use uncharted 3?

I can also say that tomb raider is re introducing Lara and should be compared to the original uncharted, which introduced drake


Because it sucks and the devs openly said they rushed it out the door. Thus again unfair comparison.
---
http://billysan291.deviantart.com/
PSN: Billysan291 3DS FC:4914-2847-6766
#37Legend524Posted 8/28/2014 3:44:25 AM
Lol both 1 and 3 are better used for this comparison than using the best in the series to go against the first in another series.

rise of tombraider should be compared to uncharted 2, which is by far the best uncharted game as of now. It's not fair for tomb raider.
#38BillysanPosted 8/28/2014 4:05:26 AM(edited)
Legend524 posted...
rise of tombraider should be compared to uncharted 2, which is by far the best uncharted game as of now. It's not fair for tomb raider.


Why the Tomb Raider reboot is like the 13th game in the series.


Maybe Tomb Raider 1 for PS1 and Uncharted 1 would be a better comparison...
---
http://billysan291.deviantart.com/
PSN: Billysan291 3DS FC:4914-2847-6766
#39gothmog87Posted 8/28/2014 4:47:56 AM
It's pretty clear for me
UC2>TR>>>>UC3>>>>UC1
I can clearly say that I like UC2 more, but the other parts don't stand a chance against TR
---
Last of Us, on the other hand, looks barely better than a PS2 game.
~icewolf74 1/11/2014 9:15:11 PM
#40blackerfire_Posted 8/28/2014 6:40:44 AM
gothmog87 posted...
I can clearly say that I like UC2 more, but the other parts don't stand a chance against TR

Maybe most wouldn't, but I'd still pick UC over TR for the reasons stated in my original post.