I visited the caverns on Day Two and discovered the ray of light that you're able to question. I can't remember whether I asked all the questions (which would mean something went wrong), or only a few of them, but I left before anything else happened. The next day (in real life), my friend told me that he had snapped a photograph of the light, so I looked on the Internet to find what I'd done wrong, and discovered that after asking ALL the questions, Nigel asks to see the spirit. So I went back, on Day Three, and tried it, but nothing happened.
Does the event only occur on Day Two, or is there something wrong with my game?