Course it shouldn't.You don't need smite top lane.
Garen with 3 Black Cleavers and that stupid Lifesteal Tiamat is OP is FCK. Try it.
this should not workhttp://sphotos-a.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash4/481647_4716971958706_243748252_n.jpg
I think they were expecting AP assassin's to counter that. You are going to be super squishy if you go for that type of build and you wont have any MR. A LeBlanc should explode you instantly.
You are not allowed to request a sticky.