Static Shiv vs. Phantom Dancer on ADCs?

#1Earthbound360Posted 1/15/2013 4:49:44 PM
Which one would you say is better? My friends argue that Phancer is better, but just going by a guide on Solomid, they seem to prefer the Shiv.

Thoughts?
---
You know 1% milk? If it's 1% milk, what's the other 99% of white stuff?
General Screenname Name: Mik! || Monster Hunter Profile in Quote
#2Flare the EchidnaPosted 1/15/2013 4:51:25 PM
Shiv for pushing, PD when you need crits.
#3Black_AssassinPosted 1/15/2013 4:51:51 PM
Shiv supposedly gives you more power for it's cost if you buy it early.
#4Shiny_PidgeyPosted 1/15/2013 4:52:25 PM
PD gives more stats, but Shiv has a better build path, a strong passive, and more MS. Generally, the more AS you have, the better Shiv becomes.
#5_HeXPosted 1/15/2013 4:53:09 PM
Depends on the adc imo, some adcs like Ezreal have a spamable ability that benefits a lot from having shiv.
---
Going to church doesn't make you a Christian any more than standing in a garage makes you a car.
#6hibbijoPosted 1/15/2013 4:53:13 PM
Shiv is better because it has a higher skill cap.
---
JOGU.WEBS.COM
~Is my creative side? >.O
#7joonyoungiePosted 1/15/2013 5:00:17 PM(edited)
If you're super fed IE+PD is still going to net you the most damage. BT+Shyv is more cost efficient and better on ADC's with slow wave clears. IE+Shyv for LOL lightning dmg
---
http://i.imgur.com/fiZMB.jpg http://i.imgur.com/TeSHa.jpg http://i.imgur.com/rBBQG.jpg http://i.imgur.com/xUh6r.png
#8Earthbound360(Topic Creator)Posted 1/15/2013 5:31:47 PM
Between Graves and Caitlyn lets say.
---
You know 1% milk? If it's 1% milk, what's the other 99% of white stuff?
General Screenname Name: Mik! || Monster Hunter Profile in Quote
#9UnderwaterAirPosted 1/15/2013 5:32:46 PM
Graves, I'd go Shiv most of the time.
Caitlyn, I'd go PD most of the time.
---
http://oi41.tinypic.com/9ht4ea.jpg
No matter which way you slice it you'll both be ending up in Hell!
#10BeerBongJohnPosted 1/16/2013 9:37:12 AM
The reason why you're seeing so many pros building Shyv+BT is because of the current strategy.

Made famous by m5 and perfected by the Korean teams, balls to the wall aggression leading to early towers and early team phase is currently the strategies used in most tournaments.

This seems to be the best way to counter zzz farm matches that Clg employed allowing them to win games even though Wicked and Hotshot gets camped and loses lane terribly.

For this reason Shyv+BT is ideal because it allows you to do relevant damage in team fights early on. Where as if you were building IE+PD you probably wouldn't have either item finished.

For most of us mid level Elo or Normal match players if you're not taking early towers and have the chance to farm by all means IE+PD.

*what I do when i'm not sure*Try building vamp, bfsword, and zeal. This is a decent(not always best) core on most ADCs. From there gauge for yourself how you think the flow of the match is going and build accordingly.

Also like someone posted above, Some ADC's have great single target damage but very little AOE or wave clear, you might want to build Shyv on someone like Vayne. Especially if you find yourself constantly being pushed to tower by that bully Caitlyn.
---
0% Class
100% A**