This is a split board - You can return to the Split List for other boards.

Creature Swap vs. Dark Illusion

#1FredCat07Posted 6/16/2009 4:37:43 PM
I am pretty sure that Dark Illusion negate this spell when it choice the only Dark Monster, namely Ultimate Nightmare. But Creature Swap also stated that it did not target, only let opponent and owner to select their respect monster, is that true?

Player A - Summoned Sabersaurus then activate Creature Swap and selected Sabersaurus
Player B - Either two ways; 1, Chain Dark Illusion and negate the activate of Creature Swap or 2, Select Ultimate Nightmare as result of Creature Swap's effect

Thanks for your respond if you do. I am little slow with this trap...
---
All Hail the FredCat!! ~Blam
Brawl Code: 1676-3646-9077
#2FredCat07(Topic Creator)Posted 6/16/2009 4:43:23 PM
Bump
---
All Hail the FredCat!! ~Blam
Brawl Code: 1676-3646-9077
#3Blackbird_1986Posted 6/16/2009 4:46:50 PM

Dark Illusion cannot stop Creature swap because the effect does not target. The monster whose control will be switched are chosen at Resolution.

#4FredCat07(Topic Creator)Posted 6/16/2009 4:47:50 PM
Thanks, so that I would not be fear to be force into attacking my opponent's Ultimate Nightmare thanks to "Battle Mania" effect.
---
All Hail the FredCat!! ~Blam
Brawl Code: 1676-3646-9077
#5darkwolf777Posted 6/16/2009 4:48:58 PM
Creature Swap does not target. Dark Illusion cannot negate it. Monsters are chosen when Creature Swap resolves, not when it is activated.
---
Super Smash Bros Brawl FC: 1762-2372-4383
Location: Buffalo, NY Nickname: DKWLF; PSN: KittenSniper
#6Blackbird_1986Posted 6/16/2009 4:52:40 PM

only if the monster(s) you control are unaffected by traps like E-Hero Wildheart, but if you control monsters that are affected by traps and your opponent has Ultimate Nightmare or any other monsters, and they activate Battle Mania during your stand-by phase then you will have to attack with monsters you control for the turn that Battle Mania was activated.

Battle Mania doesn't target

#7OmniMidKnightPosted 6/16/2009 4:53:00 PM
if it doesn't target.... how can you activate dark illusion? you answered your own question....
---
Pokemon D: (Knight) 1633 0669 2077
Co-Leader/Member Of Team Taco!!
#8FredCat07(Topic Creator)Posted 6/16/2009 4:57:06 PM
darkwolf; That's why I was making sure...

Blackbird; I am not talk about Wildheart nor Battle Mania (not on first post)

OmniMidKnight; that's a reason why I am being sure not to confuse up one part of the effect of that card for other.
---
All Hail the FredCat!! ~Blam
Brawl Code: 1676-3646-9077
#9Blackbird_1986Posted 6/16/2009 5:01:10 PM

FredCat07 posted...
**Snip**

Blackbird; I am not talk about Wildheart nor Battle Mania (not on first post)

**Snip**
---
All Hail the FredCat!! ~Blam
Brawl Code: 1676-3646-9077


My response about wildheart, the other monsters like wildheart whom are unaffected by traps and battle mania was in response to the post that talked about battle mania, i know that you didn't mention it in the first post, but you did in another post make an inquiry to Battle Mania

#10OmniMidKnightPosted 6/16/2009 5:01:54 PM
Checking is fine! I was just letting you know that you had all your facts straight, and over thinking them just does more harm than anything...
---
Pokemon D: (Knight) 1633 0669 2077
Co-Leader/Member Of Team Taco!!