Can't we all just agree that we love the series and acknowledge that not everyone has had the fortune to have both systems? I'm not going to take sides, as I own both systems, but does any of this really matter? Graphics and controls? I doubt these were what drew us to the originals in the first place (especially the controls.... ughhh *shudders*). What most of us, if not all of us, enjoy most is the experience and the sense of isolation given to us through the little notes and horrors (*remembersseeing themutilated body tied to fence at 6-8 years of age*) and the soundtrack, which logically would be the same in all versions.
I already know that I'm going to buy the higher rated of the two console versions and the PSP version (so I have a copy for the road/study hall).