The Best VGM of Super Mario Galaxy 1&2 ~ Round 1, Day 1!

#1111095Posted 4/20/2012 10:02:44 AM
Welcome to the beginning of a brand nee competition on the SMG2 board, to discover the best piece of music from both Galaxy games! Rules of round 1 are as follows...

Each song is rated out of 10 by the voters.

The average rating is calculated and used to determine the overall score.

The number of songs that will go through to round 2 will be unknown for you guys.

You only get to rate each song once, and you can't change your given score.

Be a troll and your scored will become irrelevant.

Make sure to listen to the whole song if you are unsure on it before hand (The most accurate results are wanted)

Get excited for the following rounds. Yes, its a rule. ^_^

Voting will only last 24 hours, so if you know you'll be gone for a day and you don't PM me your scores, then thats your fault! :P

Scale:

1 - Horrific!
2 - really bad
3 - Poor
4 - Below par
5 - Average
6 - Decent
7 - Good
8 - Awesome
9 - Amazing
10 - Unbelievable

Try vote as accuaretly as you can please according to the scale :)

Here we go from the random number generator!

29.) Bowser's Star Reactor (SMG) - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_gS2jO2PjM -

38.) Spin-Dig Galaxy (SMG2) - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xmzavp3-Mxw -

31.) Comet Observatory (SMG) - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qW7pdX7pDM0 -

Scores will be a running total so add them to the last total... And yes I will be voting. :P
---
Call me Stamford. http://imgur.com/a/WyllZ#0 - EddieWeMissU
This line is dedicated to Maria. The best person ever :)
#2BlanketPIPosted 4/20/2012 10:55:59 AM(edited)
Wait, I ain't supposed to vote in this thread? That seems to make this thread useless for the most part. You might as well just make 1 thread to hold everything. Unless you are going to reveal them in this thread after the day is up?

Edit: What should the topic title be? Should I explain my answers? I think you gave too little information on this!

Edit 2: I sent you a Private Message with the header "The Best VGM of Super Mario Galaxy 1&2 ~ Round 1, Day 1 Vote" and explained my vote. I hope this is sufficient and is not going too far in any direction.
---
I am socially dysfunctional; I apologize in advance, for any showing of this.
God does not damn people, for he is all merciful. Damnation is from the church.
#3FakatopaterePosted 4/20/2012 12:12:26 PM
I don't think that's the case. He just said that if we know we will be gone when a new matchup is on, we should PM him our scores instead so we don't miss the voting.
---
An old man once told me: "No old man is to be trusted".
3DS FC: 0302 - 0503 - 0747
#4111095(Topic Creator)Posted 4/20/2012 12:30:26 PM
^ Correct.

POST VOTING HERE!
---
Call me Stamford. http://imgur.com/a/WyllZ#0 - EddieWeMissU
This line is dedicated to Maria. The best person ever :)
#5FakatopaterePosted 4/20/2012 12:46:22 PM
Bowser's Star Reactor (SMG): 8/10

Spin Dig Galaxy (SMG2): 6/10

Comet Observatory (SMG): 9/10
---
An old man once told me: "No old man is to be trusted".
3DS FC: 0302 - 0503 - 0747
#6BlanketPIPosted 4/20/2012 12:56:40 PM
Oh, I misinterpreted that. This is just copy and paste, so it is really easy for me to post.

Bowser's Star Reactor: 7, It is a good piece, with the right instruments and everything, but it needs more flair to be great, if you ask me.
Spin-Dig Galaxy: 3, It is happy, but it is so bland and pointless, not to mention, it does not really feel all that much like a Mario song.
Comet Observatory: 5
#1 would be a 6, for being a bit cute and having decent instruments
#2 would be a 5, for being a bit... too elegant for what it is supposed to be, but still being a good piece overall
#3 would be a 5, for being a bit too grand and having too many instruments but it still captures that grand feeling which would be great if the place were elegant

Please note that I am using 5 as average, which means fairly good, unlike what is common in reviews, where 7 is fairly good. Why have so many levels of dreck, when there are very few pieces worthy of any of those levels? If you want me to adjust, I will, but I think this is right.
---
I am socially dysfunctional; I apologize in advance, for any showing of this.
God does not damn people, for he is all merciful. Damnation is from the church.
#7SuperMarioGamerPosted 4/20/2012 2:36:32 PM
Bowser's Star Reactor (SMG): 6/10

Spin Dig Galaxy (SMG2): 4/10

Comet Observatory (SMG): 8/10
---
Winner of Big Mario Bros. 7!
Winner of The Hidden Race!
#8Beemario123Posted 4/21/2012 10:08:52 AM
29.) Bowser's Star Reactor (SMG) - 7/10

38.) Spin-Dig Galaxy (SMG2) - 3/10

31.) Comet Observatory (SMG) - 8/10
---
(>'-')>Welcome To KirbehVille (>'-')>
#9111095(Topic Creator)Posted 4/21/2012 11:40:57 AM
From me:

Bowser's Star Reactor (SMG): 9/10

Spin Dig Galaxy (SMG2): 4/10

Comet Observatory (SMG): 7/10

Overall:

Bowser's Star Reactor (SMG): 37/50

Spin Dig Galaxy (SMG2): 19/50

Comet Observatory (SMG): 37/50

Percentages have been taken and voting is over...

Next day will start soon!
---
Call me Stamford. http://imgur.com/a/WyllZ#0 - EddieWeMissU
This line is dedicated to Maria. The best person ever :)