Eradan the ranger? Farin the dwarf? or Andriel the elf?
I'll be going with Farin right from the start. I've been a fan of Gimli ever sense I saw the frist movie and became more of a fan of the dwarves after reading the books. I hope the new Hobbit movie does them justice and shows how badass they are.
Wish they would have had four classes instead, like make the elf the main bowman and throw in Radagast as the wizard. Although doing that might conflict with the lore depending on if it goes into detail on what he was doing during the war of the ring.
Games that average a 9.0 from both IGN and Gamespot are few and far between, compared to the number of releases in this console generation alone. If that is truly your standard, then I'm afraid you've missed out on a great deal, but to each his own.