Kaidan Alenko or Ashley Williams? Spoiler

#1jrr18Posted 1/1/2013 9:12:47 PM
Which one should die on virmire? - Results (369 votes)
Ashley Williams
45.53% (168 votes)
168
Kaidan Alenko
54.47% (201 votes)
201
This poll is now closed.
any thoughts?
---
Victory over the 2013 zombie apocalypse through superior fire power!
PSN jrr101
#2CharmilePosted 1/1/2013 9:14:28 PM
The question comes down to usually the following 3 criterion

Powers
Romance
Story

1 will pick Ashley every time, 1 will pick Kaidan every time and the third will be a toss up depending on your Shepard
---
The problem with restraining speech is, who gets to set the rules? If it's only okay in a certain time or place, who gets to say what time and what place?
#3Wii0playerPosted 1/1/2013 9:36:36 PM
It's hard to say. Ashley has more depth to her character...I believe, but I have yet to do a ME3 playthrough where I romanced Kaidan...or kept him alive so idk.
---
"In Mass Effect 3, the path to victory is less clear at the outset. You wont just find some long-lost Reaper off button."-Casey ******* Hudson.
#4Rain_DustPosted 1/1/2013 9:43:15 PM
Thought it was to vote who lives.. Oh well. But seeing both sides in all 3 I have to say that keeping Kaiden is the best. Ash was pretty much forced on you in the 3rd. Very sobby and whiny.
---
Estiah, the best free online game! Join and have me as your mentor!
http://www.estiah.com/user/register/index/id/14471
#5Urdnot_RuntPosted 1/1/2013 9:45:17 PM
Ashley is the correct answer
---
You have one or more unread System Notifications. Please read them as soon as possible
^^ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZEf5VFKplzw
#6NickiousPosted 1/1/2013 10:08:39 PM(edited)
Ashley. Kaiden rubbed off the wrong way in ME3. I want reave but I haven't had the stomach to come through with a import for him.
---
"But... it was so artistically done." Thrawn
#7BingKafeiPosted 1/1/2013 10:11:04 PM
I don't hate Kaiden and unlike a few Mass Effect players didn't enjoy the idea of losing anyone. Hell, I've got the Paragon symbol tattooed on my shoulder! But I usually picked Ashley to live.
Partly because Ashley had more to live for (a family of little sisters looking up to their tough hero, vs Kaidan who had nothing but some old military pals like Shep) and partly because I enjoyed her company more (Kaidan saying he wanted to talk to me, all googly-eyed vs Ashley nervously saying "Ma'am..." to all my shameless flirting) and partly because Ashley was more useful in combat to me (Girl can wear heavy armor and take a heavy beating. Kaidan can't.)
#8windfoxxPosted 1/1/2013 10:14:22 PM
I actually never disliked Kaiden in ME1, and find him quite a bit more likable in ME3. Ashley pissed me off always questioning my motives the way she did. Plus, I think Kaiden has better powers in ME3...Ashley didn't really synergize well with my teams.
#9meltor13Posted 1/1/2013 10:15:27 PM
Urdnot_Runt posted...
Ashley is the correct answer

---
MarioKart 64 Main: Bowser
GT: MELTOR13
#10dl61695Posted 1/1/2013 10:16:50 PM
Kill Ashley she's useless especially in ME3 since you have James.
Also Kaidan has better powers.
---
PSN: lara1327
Waiting for: DmC, Bioshock Infinite, Dead Space 3, Tomb Raider, Dragon Age 3