This Board has come to a consensus on the DLC...

#1roo10158Posted 2/14/2014 9:34:17 PM
The moment you've all been waiting for, the overall opinions from this board on all the major DLCs in the trilogy!

Overall:
------------Mass Effect 1-----------
Bring Down the Sky: Most have it and like it
Pinnacle Station: Most have it and think it is meh, or don't have it at all

------------Mass Effect 2-----------
Normandy Crash Site: Most have it and like it or think it's meh
Firewalker Pack: Most have it and think it's meh
Zaeed: The Price of Revenge: Most have it and like it
Kasumi: Stolen Memory: Most have it and like it
Overlord: Most have it and like it
Lair of the Shadow Broker: Most have it and like it
Arrival: Most have it and like it

------------Mass Effect 3-----------
From Ashes: Most have it and like it
Leviathan: Most have it and like it
Omega: Some have it and like it, Some have it and think it is meh, and Some don't have it at all
Citadel: Most have it and liked it

--------------------------

To be more specific, here is the results of each. The formatting is as follows:
"Name of the DLC": (% of have it and like it; % of have it but think it's meh; % of have it but don't like it; % of don't have it)

------------Mass Effect 1-----------
Bring Down the Sky: (65.14%; 18.35%; 2.29%; 14.22%)
Pinnacle Station: (12.5%; 37.50%; 11.25%; 38.75%)

------------Mass Effect 2-----------
Normandy Crash Site: (42.24%; 47.42%; 7.22%; 4.12%)
Firewalker Pack: (21.82%; 49.05%; 21.82%; 7.27%)
Zaeed: The Price of Revenge: (73.56%; 13.79%; 1.15%; 11.49%)
Kasumi: Stolen Memory: (80.72%; 10.84%; 1.20%; 7.23%)
Overlord: (56.16%; 23.29%; 2.74%; 17.81%)
Lair of the Shadow Broker: (86.15%; 3.08%; 3.08%; 7.69%)
Arrival: (61.70%; 19.15%; 4.26%; 14.89%)

------------Mass Effect 3-----------
From Ashes: (70.59%; 11.76%; 1.18%; 16.47%)
Leviathan: (66.67%; 16.67%; 1.67%; 15.00%)
Omega: (31.43%; 32.86%; 2.86%; 32.86%)
Citadel: (85.07%; 0.00%; 1.49%; 13.43%)
---
Will preorder- Mass Effect 4 Collector's Edition
Top 5 franchises- Mass Effect, Mario, Sonic, Batman, & Pokemon
#2roo10158(Topic Creator)Posted 2/14/2014 9:51:12 PM(edited)
So, this means that according to the results, the DLCs from best to worst are:

1. Lair of the Shadow Broker
2. Citadel
3. Kasumi: Stolen Memory
4. Zaeed: The Price of Revenge
5. From Ashes
6. Leviathan
7. Bring Down the Sky
8. Arrival
9. Overlord
10. Normandy Crash Site
11. Omega
12. Firewalker Pack
13. Pinnacle Station


Another thing to note is the prices for these DLCs to help put them in a little more perspective (this is not PS3 prices, since it has a lot more of these included with the games themselves):

~Free~
Normandy Crash Site
Firewalker Pack
Zaeed: The Price of Revenge

~$1.00~
Bring Down the Sky

~$4.99~
Pinnacle Station

~$6.99~
Kasumi: Stolen Memory
Overlord
Arrival

~$9.99~
Lair of the Shadow Broker
From Ashes
Leviathan

~$14.99~
Omega
Citadel
---
Will preorder- Mass Effect 4 Collector's Edition
Top 5 franchises- Mass Effect, Mario, Sonic, Batman, & Pokemon
#3pfh1001Posted 2/14/2014 11:45:06 PM
I'd bump Overlord above Arrival but am otherwise in agreement with that.
#4Talon5967Posted 2/15/2014 12:35:08 AM
Also in agreement. There's some I liked better than the ones placed above them, but when you add in prices differences, it evens out.
---
There are 10 types of people in the world. Those that know binary, and those that don't.
GT:Talon Omega. If you send an FR please tell me where you got my GT.
#5TimeShinigamiPosted 2/15/2014 7:05:33 AM
I think Leviathan is way to high. Twas bad.
---
Not changing this sig until the Detroit Lions win the Super Bowl.
GT- ShinigamiOfTime
#6Offworlder1Posted 2/15/2014 9:38:18 AM
I find this accurate, nice list and nice organization putting it together TC.
---
"Always two there are, a master and an apprentice"
#7NefhithPosted 2/15/2014 9:42:51 AM
roo10158 posted...
13. Pinnacle Station


I'll respect your opinion, but I think your opinion sucks.

But it's pretty accurate. A good way to feed people's curiosity.
---
"panda is probably a rocket launcher" - MisterBellic