Is this RPG the best RPG you played on the PS 3, Xbox 360, or Wii?

#41lazycomplifePosted 1/24/2013 12:15:33 PM
musumane posted...
If we limit it to PS3/360/Wii its top 5, if we include PSP its top 10, if we include DS, top 15 maybe? Throw in 3DS and Vita it goes to top 20.

My list for those who are wondering

1) Tales of Vesperia (360)
2) VC ( PS3)
3) Persona 3 Portable
4) Persona 4 The Golden
5) Persona 2 Innocent SIn
6) Radiant Historia
7) Pokemon Black/White 2
8) Lost Odyssey
9) Tales of the Abyss 3DS
10) Diseaga 4
11) Pokemon Platinum
12) Growlanser Wayfer of Time
13) SMT Strange Journey
14) Devil Survivor Overclocked
15) Legend of Heroes: Trails
16) FFT: WoTL
17) Ni no Kuni
18) Xenoblade
19) Rune Factory 3
20) Tales of Graces F


Keep in mind these are all 8/10 or higher games to me


Good list :)
---
Wow really
Official Swinub of Pokemon X and Y boards
#42SkriblZzPosted 1/24/2013 12:18:16 PM
musumane posted...
If we limit it to PS3/360/Wii its top 5, if we include PSP its top 10, if we include DS, top 15 maybe? Throw in 3DS and Vita it goes to top 20.

My list for those who are wondering

1) Tales of Vesperia (360)
2) VC ( PS3)
3) Persona 3 Portable
4) Persona 4 The Golden
5) Persona 2 Innocent SIn
6) Radiant Historia
7) Pokemon Black/White 2
8) Lost Odyssey
9) Tales of the Abyss 3DS
10) Diseaga 4
11) Pokemon Platinum
12) Growlanser Wayfer of Time
13) SMT Strange Journey
14) Devil Survivor Overclocked
15) Legend of Heroes: Trails
16) FFT: WoTL
17) Ni no Kuni
18) Xenoblade
19) Rune Factory 3
20) Tales of Graces F


Keep in mind these are all 8/10 or higher games to me


Really Growlanser? I didn't hear many good things. Nice to see Vesperia is on your top, as well.
---
PSN: Skribz666 | Xbox Live: SkriblZz | Nintendo Network: SkriblZz
#43JzkBoxerPosted 1/24/2013 12:25:47 PM
I'll never understand the profound hatred WRPG and JRPG fans seem to have for one another. Am I the only one who likes both?
#44ZenGamer64Posted 1/24/2013 12:28:37 PM
NashtheLion posted...
If you've never played Dark Souls you are seriously missing out.

This gen:
Demons Souls and Dark Souls

Bar none


For action games, without a doubt.
---
I can stare at a knot in a piece of wood
until it frightens me.
#45SkriblZzPosted 1/24/2013 12:29:49 PM
JzkBoxer posted...
I'll never understand the profound hatred WRPG and JRPG fans seem to have for one another. Am I the only one who likes both?


I like both, but JRPG moreso. There's just a lot of boring things WRPG do. Skyrim is boring, I personally do not care for the lore at all. Same with WoW, same Diablo. It's all just kinda boring to me.
---
PSN: Skribz666 | Xbox Live: SkriblZz | Nintendo Network: SkriblZz
#46generalhsPosted 1/24/2013 12:31:13 PM
JzkBoxer posted...
I'll never understand the profound hatred WRPG and JRPG fans seem to have for one another. Am I the only one who likes both?


I'm a big fan of both. They bring different things to the table, though strangely I'm put off when they're combined too much like in Xenoblade.

I like Ni no Kuni and the Tales games. I also love Baldurs Gate, Skyrim and Mass Effect. I consider Dark Souls more of an action-rpg than true RPG since there isn't much roleplaying involved there and i don't mean that as a slight against the game either.
#47JzkBoxerPosted 1/24/2013 12:34:04 PM
generalhs posted...
JzkBoxer posted...
I'll never understand the profound hatred WRPG and JRPG fans seem to have for one another. Am I the only one who likes both?


I'm a big fan of both. They bring different things to the table, though strangely I'm put off when they're combined too much like in Xenoblade.

I like Ni no Kuni and the Tales games. I also love Baldurs Gate, Skyrim and Mass Effect. I consider Dark Souls more of an action-rpg than true RPG since there isn't much roleplaying involved there and i don't mean that as a slight against the game either.


Yeah see, this is me almost exactly. I don't even see the separation between the two. They're different, but a good rpg is a good rpg to me.
#48MoooglemanPosted 1/24/2013 12:38:27 PM
Easily
#49stekim40Posted 1/24/2013 12:40:15 PM
Morrowind - PC
---
Playing: Far Cry 3, PC Minecraft, Skyrim , F1 2012
Waiting for: ELITE:Dangerous, GTA V, Pikmin 3, Dragon Age 3
#50tadpinoyPosted 1/24/2013 12:42:35 PM
No.