NHL '94

"Virtual hockey nirvana"

NHL '94 is remembered by some as the pinnacle of hockey gaming from the 16-bit era. The game was EA's third installment of the series, and the first to have licensing from both the NHL and NHLPA. While that is something we come to expect from hockey games today, it gave EA added authenticity that was that made it stand out from previous hockey games.

Gameplay
NHL '94 uses the same engine that NHLPA '93 uses. It is for that reason some think of this game as simply a rehashed version of '93, though that isn't really the case. The players do move a little faster, and they don't stop on a dime either, which provides frustration and realism. Either way you look at it, it takes some getting used to. There is still no difficulty setting to change, so players from all skill levels play against the same AI every time. Overall the gameplay is smooth. Players move at a reasonable pace given the size of the rink, checking can be a two-way street, and teams for average players will score what you'd expect from an NHL game. Passing is my biggest qualm with the gameplay. The direction you choose to pass is not always responded too, and players seem to mishandle the easiest of passes at times. Passing is essential to the biggest edition to the gameplay in '94; the one-timer. This very move changed the series greatly, as it presented a whole new dimension to the offense. You don't need to utilize this at all to win, but it is easily the most deadly weapon offensively if used correctly. While there is addition, there is also subtraction; there is no fighting in this game. Fighting was a big part of NHLPA '93, almost too big a part, and in order to get both NHL and NHLPA licenses EA dropped the fighting all together. All other penalties are enforced the same, but the game just doesn't feel right without any fighting at all. Players can still get injured for the period or game, but no blood.

The usual suspects of game modes returns with Exhibition, Single Game Playoffs, and Best of 7 Playoffs. There is a new shootout mode, which gets old rather quick. Use it as a practice mode to work on your breakaway scoring or goalie-work if you prefer using manual goalie. There is a new record keeper that is used at the discretion of the player to track their overall record and highs for goals and saves. If you're like me and play a lot of games, it's a nice way to keep track of things, and even more interesting if you play against other friends records.
Score: 8

Graphics
The game looks a bit sharper than '93, but the Sega CD doesn't seem to look much better than the Genesis version. There is a FMV intro to the game that is pretty well done and could certainly pass on an early PSX hockey title. There are new player cards for a lot of the players in the game, some do a good job of capturing the players' face well and others don't. They are all in black and white and look a bit grainy. Oddly enough Ron Barr's profile picture is in color though. The crowd theatrics are pretty good, not that you'll really notice. The checking is also done pretty well. The game looks decent for its time, though doesn't really take advantage of what the Sega CD had to offer.
Score: 6

Sound
NHL '94 really shines here. There are a ton of new songs in the game, each arena has specific titles that are played to give more authenticity to the game. The intro song is done very well and has been upgraded over the Genesis version. Ron Barr even talks as he gives you team and player profiles at the beginning of every game! Throughout your game, you'll constantly hear the crowd, and they do a nice job of acting accordingly. Even when paused you'll hear them, the way you would if you were in the hallway of the arena going to get a hot dog. This is a very nice touch that makes you feel more apart of the game. The sound effects also sound more polished than the Genesis version. You'll definitely notice you're playing the Sega CD version of the game.
Score: 8

Replayability
There is no season mode in this game, which is a bummer. The game sells itself on the gameplay, which should keep you playing for a while. Regardless of what time period you play this game, you will always be going back for more.
Score: 8

Final Recommendation
If you're a fan of EA's NHL games from the 16-bit era, you'll like this game. There is great gameplay to be had here, and if you buy this game, you buy it knowing you aren't getting an in-depth season mode, but a great hockey game you can play over and over again. This was EA's only offering of the franchise on the Sega CD, and it stands as the best hockey game the system has to offer. Of the 3 versions released of this game (Genesis, Sega CD, SNES) this is the best version. Though this is the most polished of the 3, I can't recommend getting it if you already another one of them. Otherwise, this is a sports classic you must have for your Sega CD.

Reviewer's Score: 8/10, Originally Posted: 09/26/05