Question from XAnimehottieX

Asked: 5 years ago

How can I get Carl to return?

Carl left and I've decided after looking around town for which person I want to marry and he is the one, but he's left the town, and I need him to come back, does anyone know how?

This question is open with pending answers, but none have been accepted yet

Submitted Answers


Ship eggs and milk.

Rated: +0 / -2

Ship eggs, Milk, breadfruit, cocoa, etc.
Anything you might need to make Desserts


Rated: +1 / -2

Just ship lots of eggs and after a few days, Carl (and Katie) would come back to the village.

Rated: +0 / -2

You have to ship sweets ingredients. Cocoas, Breadfruits, milk, and eggz. Don't worry, the same thing happend to me and he returned in a little more then a week!

Rated: +0 / -1

So you don't have to ship eggs AND milk? eggs is just fine????

Rated: +0 / -0

for me they just came back. I didnt ship any thing along those lines sence I didnt have a cow yet.

Rated: +0 / -1

Ship anything that is needed to make sweets.Things like eggs,milk,cocoa,ect.

Rated: +1 / -1

Forget what I said. Once I just shipped 5 eggs (any type from this group: egg, good egg, special egg), and the next day Carl came back.

Rated: +0 / -0

Ship any sweets or start a new file and talk to him more so he doesn't leave in the first place.

Rated: +0 / -0

Respond to this Question

You must be logged in to answer questions. Please use the login form at the top of this page.

Similar Questions