Review by RathOsiris

"KOTOR 1 or KOTOR 2, which is better? (Since you ask the forums constantly)"

I just beat it light side(Jedi Guardian/Jedi Weapon Master) and am on my Dark side(Jedi Consular/Sith Assassin) play through.

Main Features, this one upgrades KOTOR 1 completely. Especially with the new upgrade system (Pure genius to let me craft it) - I think I bought maybe 10 items from the stores all game. And that was HK or Lightsaber related stuff that I couldn't make.

Storyline wise, so far the KOTOR 2 ending is great for lightisde. Though I do dislike some aspects of it, it was more in depth, and even told of the future some. I havent played Dark Side all the way through, so I can't say much on that side.

Characters, the characters on this one kick major ass. You'll see some of your old favorites, you'll loathe some, you'll love some. It's like a really good book. I am still mad at a few of my characters =) I give KOTOR 2 the win in this sector.

Planets, I like that you revisit some old ones, but that it's mainly new ones. I'm giving KOTOR 1 this one, though. Tatooine and Kashyyk were just kick ass.

Feats/Powers, KOTOR 2, again, upgraded KOTOR 1s system. I am pretty sure by looking at the differences that KOTOR 2 abandoned the stricter D20 rules. But it still obeys some and uses that system. It really makes the game more enjoyable and gives you more options. KOTOR 2 comes out with a flawless victory.

Graphics, iKOTOR 2 is newer, so of course.. it's upgraded here. Not drastically, and at times you notice a slow down. But I give KOTOR 2 the win here, too. It just looks better. Especially the combat of Lightsaber vs Lightsaber.

Overall, I say KOTOR 1 had a more shocking story. However, KOTOR 2 had a far more intriguing and in depth story. I'd recommend playing 1 then 2, a great deal. Or else all game you will wonder who Revan is. (He's mentioned ALL the way through) - But I wouldn't let KOTOR 2 slip past your grasp.

Why did I give it a 9 and not a 10 you ask? The laggy slow down at times and the one time the game froze up cost it that last point. =P


Reviewer's Score: 9/10 | Originally Posted: 12/10/04


Would you recommend this Review? Yes No
Commenting is anonymous and not required to vote.
Submit Recommendation

Got Your Own Opinion?

You can submit your own review for this game using our Review Submission Form.